Thursday, January 13, 2011

The BCS Farce

The bowl game between #1 and #2 is over.  Auburn wins by just a field goal.  So Auburn and TCU end the season with undefeated records.  Yet, Auburn is #1 and TCU isn't?  What silly methodology is this?  Shouldn't the undefeated team be the only team to proclaim that they are #1?  Only in America can you find such a stupid playoff system.

The Bowl Championship Series (BCS) is college football's profitable money making machine.  Its purpose is to generate revenue for all the colleges and universities which it does by promoting the College Bowl games.  However, the money that is received isn't divided equally.  But money is another topic of discussion.

What irks me about the BCS isn't the money or the uneven disbursement of money.  It is about the promotion of "unsportsmanlike" conduct.  During the college football season, there are advertisements from the conferences that promote the good morals of the school and the conferences in order to entice future applicants.  Morals?  Where is the morality of powerhouse schools running up the score on weaker schools?  In fact, I believe the BCS encourages teams to disregard any sense of common sense that was taught in youth sports.  The ranking system lies at the heart of this problem.

I am positive it is every college football team's dream to play for the national championship title.  To do so, there needs to be a ranking system.  The BCS system was established in order to "properly" rank college teams in order to allow bowl committees from around the nation to choose who to invite to play at the committee's respective bowl game.  The higher a team is ranked, the more prestigious of a bowl a team can play in.  

The ranking system involves a combination of qualitative opinions (Coaches poll, Harris poll) as well as quantitative data from computer generated results based off various tangible data (win-loss, strength of schedule, location).  Unfortunately, the methodology of combining qualitative and quantitative data places more weight on the qualitative opinions.  Each of the polls are weighted equally.  But since the two of the three polls are "opinion polls," opinion polls have a higher weight than the computer polls.  In the end, the polls get weighted 

I have three issues with this ranking system.

1)  The weighting system places more emphasis on the two opinion polls (Coaches and Harris) instead of the computer polls.  The computer polls only look at quantitative data such as win-loss of teams, the score differential and strength of schedule.  Because of the more emphasis on the opinion polls, the "wow factors" like margin of victory, and personal preferences are factored more into the overall calculation which affects the weekly ranking.  

I believe rankings should not be devoid of personal opinions.  It should however not be over emphasized as it is currently with the BCS system.  This would prevent teams from attempting to influence the opinion polls through their play against opponents.

For example, if Team A beats Team B by 40+ points, the qualitative polls will naturally assume that the Team A is better regardless if Team B is of even the same caliber as Team A.  At the start of every new football season, many strong football teams invite weaker football teams to play.  The net result is that the strong football team will win and win by a lot.  If you look here at the 2009 BCS Champion Alabama, they played three schools that were hardly of the same caliber -- FIU (Florida International), Chattanooga, and North Texas.  The combined record for all three teams were 11-24 for 2009.  Chattanooga wasn't even a Division 1-A school and they had the best record at 6-5.  Alabama beat these schools 40-14, 45-0 and 53-7.  Alabama basically obtained three automatic victories playing against these lesser known and weaker schools.  Is it possible that Alabama ran up the score in order to influence the Coaches and Harris polls?  Yes I believe so.

2)  The computer polls do not punish strong teams that play against weak teams.  By punishing strong teams for playing weaker teams, it will force these strong schools to play other similar caliber schools which would lead to a more accurate ranking.  Does Alabama really deserve the "National Champion" title even though they played three weak schools?  If those three weak schools were replaced by USC, Boise State, and Ohio State, would Alabama still have an undefeated record?  Could Alabama really handle the pressure situation of facing top ranked schools so early in the season?

3)  The ranking system does not expand beyond 25 teams.  There are over 100 Division 1-A teams.  Why are only the top 25 teams considered in the ranking?


My solution isn't very revolutionary.  In fact, I have two solutions -- one complicated and one simple.  

The simple solution is to organize a single elimination tournament.  Bowl season ended in the second weak of January 2010.  The first bowl game started in the second week of December 2009.  There are five weekends of play.  If the tournament starts with 64 teams, after the first week, 32 teams remain.  After the second week, 16 teams remain.  After the third week, 8 teams remain.  After the fourth week, 4 teams remain.  After the fifth week, two remain.  And on the sixth week, the championship game occurs.  This is a total of 63 games.  Thats more games than the current number of bowl games scheduled.  More games should translate to more money.

The complicated solution is to revamp the BCS ranking system.  It should include a few key points.  I think the emphasis for the new ranking system should be to encourage teams to play similarly ranked teams.  

First, the opinion poll contribution to the BCS ranking should be reduced to 20% total.  The subjectivity of opinion polls allows the voters to be swayed by teams that run up the score against laughable opponents.  This subjectivity should not be a major factor.

Second, the BCS should rank the top 100 schools.  These top 100 schools should be subdivided into an upper tier and lower tier.  These tiers should not be published as a ranked scale but only as a group.  Only the top 25 should be ranked.

Third, teams that rank in the top 100 should be punished for playing teams that are either not in Division 1A or outside the top 100 excluding their own division.  They should be punished regardless if they win and should be punished even more if they lose.  This would prevent any "top team" from bottom feeding on weaker Division 1A and 2A teams.

Complicated right?  I want to make the ranking system work in such a way that teams of equal strength should theoretically be at the similar ranks.  By being able to weed out schools that play weak teams, the system should theoretically then be able to match up the best schools to play against each other come bowl games.  Ideally, a team that plays all top tier schools and remains undefeated should be crowned #1 if it remains undefeated through such tough schedules.  Unlike... teams that play 3 unranked division 2A schools for 3 easy wins.

Friday, December 31, 2010

Wines~!



I normally don’t drink Pinot Noirs.  However a trip to the Sonoma Wine Country up in the Bay Area landed me in Healdsburg where the La Crema tasting room was located.  With some friends we tried their normal tasting flights which were decent.  The lady serving us was kind enough to allow us to try the “higher quality” wine.  She had us taste the difference between the Sonoma Coast, Russian RIver Valley and Los Carneros PInots.  There was a significant difference between Sonoma Coast and the latter two.  After whetting our appetite on these three Pinot Noirs, she brought out the Nine Barrel.

And wow!  The difference between the Nine Barrel and the other three was immediate.  The Nine Barrel left me very impressed both at the flavor and how smooth it was.  I generally do not like tannins and this one had very little comparatively speaking to the three previous PInot Noirs.

In the end, each one of us bought at least one Nine Barrel.  Her tactical whetting of our appetite brought in at least 2 bottles worth of sale.  

If you like reds and aren’t stuck with one particular varietal, I highly suggest you try this.  It might be expensive ($90/bottle) but it was worth very penny in my opnion.

Musical^2

West Side Story

For those who may never have seen the movie like me, you may have probably heard it was based off a 1960s musical with the same name.  That musical was loosely based off Shakespeare’s Romeo and Juliet.  And I can’t help you if you’ve never heard of Romeo and Juliet.

This 2009 revival was nominated for the Tony award “Best Revival” category but failed to win.  Oddly enough, it also never won the category in its previous 1980s revival attempt too.  It is currently on tour in the US and was in LA for the past month.  Go watch it to support the Arts.  I did.

I went to watch this with 3 other friends in the mezzanine area.  The location of the seats were pretty good.  Although it wasn’t as “centered” as I had hoped I think for the price and the location it was pretty decent.  The alternative seats would be down in back orchestra much further back relatively speaking than the mezzanine seats.

I thought the beginning of Act 1 was pretty boring.  I think all the dancing and choreography that was done to imitate street fights back during the 1960s was probably very unique and interesting to watch.  I think the “fight scenes” were well choreographed but just lasted a bit too long.  The acting was fun to watch since these types of “acting” musicals are a rarity.  Act 2 was a bit better.  I did find out where two songs come from: Oh So Pretty and Somewhere.  I never knew these two songs came from West Side Story.  In fact I thought Mel Brooks wrote the “oh so pretty” song since I recall him singing it in some movie musical in the past.  I also thought Barbara Streisand was the one who wrote/sung “Somewhere” and popularized it back when she was a star.



Next to Normal

The National Tour arrived in LA sometime last month.  I went to see it with a friend of mine.  We bought balcony seats which were pretty cheap.  Since we both have no expectations, the upper balcony seats were a good trade off for something that could be good or could be horrible.

From the first number, we both realized that mezzanine seats were a must.  The stage was a multi-story background that had the actors walking on all three levels.  Unfortunately We were sitting higher than the third level.  The scenes on the first level were sometimes cut off due to our viewing angle.  As the show progressed, I began to get annoyed at the female lead.  She was singing in a low octave or singing from the belly.  Whenever she sang, about 50% of her words that came out were really muffled.  Most of her songs or songs she participated in sounded like it was missing an alto or soprano voice.  At the end, it sounded as if she was either fighting a cold or trying to sing an octave too low.

Overall the show was very minimalistic... like Rent.  It featured only 5 actors.  The music also sounded very similar to Rent’s rock ballad fusion -- bits of rock, bits of classical, bits of pop.  There were definitely some songs that I liked much more.  I think I enjoyed Act 2’s music more than Act 1’s.  

I think for the price we paid, we were surprised by how good it was.  It might be worth it to pay for mezzanine and/or orchestra seats.  This musical definitely made use of the multi-story structure of the stage effectively which added more to the story.  However, if the female lead sang like she did, I probably wouldn’t want to watch it at all.

Monday, December 20, 2010

Gourmet Food Trucks (13)


Re: GourmetGenie2Go
Looking at the menu, this truck offers Mediterranean food.  I’ve seen it a few times near work at Olympic and 26th.  There’s usually a small line that moves relatively quickly.  I guess Mediterranean food can be served pretty quickly.  On this particular day, I went with a coworker who was also going to go out to lunch.  She had never been to a food truck and had always been interested in going after I usually bring back food from the trucks.  So for that day, I had great company.

I chose the “Sultan’s Feast” since it looked interesting as a combo and offerec beef and chicken shwarma..  I’ve liked shwarma ever since eating the chicken shwarma plate at the Mediterranean restaurant in the Durant Food Court days.




The plate wasn’t that good.  Because it was a shwarma plate, I expected the meat to be juicy and flavorful from being slow cooked like a rotisserie.  Unfortunately it wasn’t.  The chicken shwarma was decent but the beef didn’t taste like it belonged in the dish... maybe it was the parsley?  The cabbage salad was also bland.  I think if it added some vinegar it may have tasted better and contrasted more with the hummus.  Their hummus was the only item I liked.  It also tasted very similar to the hummus you buy at super market or even at Zankou Chicken.  I think this truck could be even better if they made a hummus that looked like the normal hummus but tasted amazingly different from the regular store bought hummus.




Re: Comfort Truck
This truck is has a “celebrity chef” who was a contestant from Season 1 of Top Chef.  I’ve seen this truck on the twitter aggregate as well as the google map aggregate that I frequent to see where the different trucks are serving food.  They have not been in Santa Monica for lunch or West LA for dinner service.  However, recently they were finally in West LA for dinner service and I took the opportunity to eat from them.

I had their BBQ chicken wrap and the corn relish.  I originally wanted to get the Chicken wrap since it was one of Chef Brian’s original suggestions as a menu item that represented the truck.  The BBQ sauce was a suggestion by the chef who said it would make the wrap taste even better.  Being the first time I’ve even been to the truck, I went with his suggestion.


The small balls at the bottom right are from Flying Pig Truck (see below)

The BBQ chicken wrap was delicious.  The sauce the chef used was sweet yet tangy and made me wanting more each bite.  I couldn’t tell what else was in each bite.  But it was good.  The corn relish wasn’t so great.  I thought it’d be almost salsa like with a vinegarette like flavoring since conjures up a profile of sweet yet tangy.  Unfortunately I only tasted the corn.  It felt like it needed at least some seasoning.




Re: Mighty Boba Truck
I think I’ve reviewed this truck awhile back for its popcorn chicken and milk tea.  I don’t remember if I mentioned that they also had a “lunch menu” that consisted mainly of the Taiwanese snacks with rice.  So you can choose from popcorn chicken, taiwanese sausages, pork chops and tofu to go along with a side of rice and vegetables.  I had the chicken and pork chops for lunch.  It was actually a decent amount of food for the price and I only finished half of it.  I like the vegetables that they included.  It was cooked with garlic and seasoned just right.  Unfortunately, I don’t have pictures.






Re: Flying Pig Truck
It’s a “can’t miss” Hot PINK TRUCK.  Their crab balls looked interesting (see above picture) so I just ordered it.  Unfortunately, it didn’t taste too good.  I think it was the honey drizzle that made it taste awful.  I remember eating this type of snacks when I went back to Taiwan at those night markets.  They were the exact size but had salt and pepper sprinkled on them.  I think having the balls be salty instead of sweet would have made this a better dish.

Monday, December 13, 2010

Gourmet Food Trucks (12)

Re:  Get Your Lard On aka the Bacon Truck
This truck was brought to my attention by a coworker.  Looking at the website, you can definitely tell this is a bacon lover’s wet dream.  Everything oozes with bacon... even the dessert!  I tried this truck one day since it was “close by.”  The guy behind the cash box suggested that I try their signature dish --” the Baco.”  Its a taco filled with potato and cheese, except instead of a normal tortilla shell, they used three strips of bacon.

Ya... I had it and it was good.  Just the smell of the bacon was intoxicating.  




Re: Greasy Wiener
A hot dog truck.  I’m not a big fan of hot dogs... let alone gourmet style hot dogs.  I’ll eat them every so often with the usual toppings of ketchup, mustard, relish and onions especially at CostCo.  But when this truck was in town, I went to try their signature “Greasy Wiener” spicy hot dog.  The heat from the hot dog was pretty good.  Their bun could have used a little bit of heat to warm it up.  It was pretty stiff when I had it.

I didn’t like their pickle that they included.  I think I prefer relish more.  Although if you watch Food Network long enough, some of the shows say the “classic method” (meaning old) hot dog preparation is with pickles.  Go figure.  I”m not a fan of sauerkraut so I don’t really know what to say about it.
They have other items on the menu that might be worth trying.  Unfortunately it’s not really at the top of my favorite’s list.



Re:  Shrimp Pimp
Similar to how Lard On truck is bacon inspired, Shrimp Pimp truck is shrimp inspired.  I’ve seen them near work a few times usually with a long line.  Generally, if there’s a long line, people probably consider their food to be decent enough to go back a second or a third time.

I tried their Shrimp and Chips.  They gave me like eight battered shrimp.  EIGHT!  They definitely aren’t skimping on the shrimp.  The shrimp itself was also pretty good.  The batter could be made a bit lighter.  I’ve had beer battered seafood in the past before and I seem to recall it wasn’t as thick.  Perhaps it’s because the dish is made in a truck and has difficulty perfecting the beer batter coating?  I enjoyed their spicy chipotle(?) dipping sauce.  I had enough of the fries to consider them decent.  My coworkers liked the fries though.  They think it tasted really good because the fries absorbed some of the beer battered shrimp flavor.



Re: Fishlips Sushi
This is a sushi truck.  Ya... Sushi and truck just doesn’t seem “safe”.  However just like Shrimp Pimp, I see this truck near work usually with a good amount of people waiting for their food.  So it can’t be that bad can it?

Well... I found out they mainly specialize in rolls.  The california roll (crab/avacado), tempura roll (shrimp tempura) and spicy tuna roll (spicy tuna) seem to be their most popular.  They do have sushi though not in the traditional sense that you find at fine dining Japanese sushi bars.  Their sushi is in the form of mini rice balls with a small slice of sashimi layered on top.  I guess... it can still be called sushi.  

Anyways, being a bit hesitant, I tried only their “fully cooked” rolls like the shrimp tempura roll.  The roll itself was decently made.  It looks even better rolled then something you would find at Ralph’s or Whole Foods.  You could even say restaurant quality rolling.  A full roll gives you 8 pieces and these pieces were decently large (maybe as large as a sit-down sushi restaurant).  The shrimp tempura was fairly typical.  It wasn’t the best tasting but it also wasn’t as horrible as Ralph’s.  It’s a pretty passable alternative to grocery market made rolls.

I would probably like to try the other rolls they have.



Re: Che Truck

Argentinian truck I had posted before.  They make good empanadas.  I’m sure there are other places that make great empanadas as well but these by far are the best ones from a truck (and so far the ONLY ones too). I highly recommend trying their empanadas if you ever get a the chance.


I highly recommend trying their empanadas if you ever get a the chance.